The High Court has lifted conservatory orders that had temporarily prohibited the Judicial Service Commission (JSC), the Chief Justice, and the State Law Office from publishing individual performance records of judges and judicial officers.
In directions issued by Justice David Mburu, the court discharged the interim restraint granted on Thursday, November 19, following an urgent petition filed by Duncan K. Kariuki challenging the planned release of the data. The initial order had barred the JSC and Chief Justice Martha Koome from releasing the performance scorecards as an addendum or appendix to the annual judicial report.
While certifying Kariuki’s application as urgent and admitting it for hearing, Justice Mburu vacated the specific clause restraining publication, observing that courts do not issue orders in vain. The ruling clears a major legal hurdle as the Judiciary unveils the State of the Judiciary and the Administration of Justice Annual Report (SOJAR) for the 2025/2026 financial year.
Push for Judicial Transparency and Case Clearance
The dispute centers on a broader institutional reform introduced by the Judiciary in May 2026 to publish individual performance scorecards tracking case clearance rates, backlog management, and case flow efficiency. Proponents argue that public reporting is a constitutional obligation necessary to address delayed justice, while critics have raised concerns over judicial independence and the fairness of raw statistical comparisons across varying court stations.
According to the newly released 2025/2026 SOJAR report, the Judiciary recorded an overall case clearance rate of 103 percent, though 341,000 cases remain pending across various court levels. Cases pending for more than a year declined by 15.8 percent over the review period, which Chief Justice Koome attributed to targeted case-management interventions and sustained performance monitoring.
The substantive constitutional questions raised in Kariuki’s petition remain active before the High Court, with parties directed to file formal submissions ahead of a mention scheduled for December 1, 2026.