In a dramatic turn of events on Wednesday, police officers executed a raid on the residence of John Matara, the prime suspect in the tragic death of 26-year-old Starlet Wahu. The investigators uncovered a disturbing array of items within Matara’s house in Kahawa West, Nairobi, providing crucial clues to unravel the mysterious circumstances surrounding the murder.
Among the items recovered were HIV testing kits, packs of condoms, empty alcohol bottles, rolls of bhang (marijuana), and chilling notes affixed to the walls containing personal information about various victims. These findings suggest a potentially sinister pattern of behavior that investigators are diligently piecing together to understand the scope of Matara’s alleged crimes.
Matara, who appeared to lead a seemingly quiet life, utilized his residence primarily for hosting women, according to detectives. The apartment’s caretaker expressed shock and disbelief at the revelation, stating, “He was a quiet person and he portrayed the character of a good person. I am shocked that he is the main suspect in this murder incident.” The caretaker further disclosed that Matara, aside from his reserved demeanor, had a penchant for alcohol and frequently entertained female guests.
It was noted that Matara preferred staying indoors during the day, emerging at night and returning in the early morning hours in the company of different women. The caretaker also disclosed Matara’s financial struggles, as he frequently sought extensions to pay rent, shedding light on potential motivations behind his alleged criminal activities.
A collage of the late Starlet Wahu (left) and John Matara (right)
Even more perplexing is the contrast presented by Matara’s childhood friends from Daraja Mbili in Kisii County. Describing him as a God-fearing Christian and a devout Seventh-Day Adventist, they expressed disbelief at the accusations. One friend stated, “I used to see him come to church early before anyone else; he knows how to sing well and was also great at giving advice.” The stark contrast between Matara’s public persona and the disturbing revelations of his private life has left those who knew him struggling to reconcile the two.
The incident, which unfolded on January 3, 2024, has prompted several women to come forward, alleging previous incidents of sexual assault and extortion by Matara. These additional claims suggest a potential pattern of predatory behavior that extends beyond the tragic case of Starlet Wahu.
As the investigation unfolds, the authorities are working tirelessly to connect the dots and bring justice to the victims. The shocking discoveries in Matara’s residence have opened a new chapter in the ongoing probe, revealing a complex and disturbing portrait of a man whose outward appearance belied the dark secrets hidden within.